Each year, an Athlete of the Year is chosen by Regina Dominican High School. Below are a list of the previous winners.
1991-Maureen Martin
1992-Amy Misch & Erin Roscoe
1993-Kristen Heinichen & Jackie Ruben
1994-Julie Martin
1995-Michelle K. Walton
1996-Erin Luby
1997-Stephanie Jost & Kathleen Ward
1998-Shante Haymore & Alexa Rockimanovich
1999-Kathleen Mitchell &Carolina Yohanan
2000-Kelly Carlstrom
2001-Jill Krause
2002-Brittany Becker
2003-Christina Quaye
2004-Jenny Stoner
2005-Lauren Schober
2006-Rosie Dorn
2007-Claire Costello
2008-Julie Stoner
2009-Folly Freund
2009-Kristin McDonald
2010 Jaqueline Ave Maria
2011-Aileen Campanaro
2012-Kati Herberg
2013-Lindsay Welch
2014-Erin French
2015-Niamh Ryan
2016-Lily Hackett
2017-Colleen Palmer
2018-Kelly French
2019-Caitlin Ward